“Is this where the elders sit?” an older woman joked as she settled into a chair near me in a library meeting room.

Eight years after the synagogue mass shooting, about 10 Pittsburghers gathered at the Carnegie Library’s Allegheny branch to consider what the memory of October 27 might ask of us at a time when immigrants were facing heightened hostility and uncertainty.

Symone Saul, one of the organizers, brought snacks and literature from Never Again Action, a Jewish-led movement opposing immigrant detention. A friendly Lutheran pastor quietly took a chair on my left. Around the table were people who had spent years organizing for immigrant rights, alongside others, like me, whose involvement was more recent.

I had volunteered to help prepare readings and discussion questions, although I left the facilitation to friends from the Jewish community who had lived in Pittsburgh during the shooting. Having moved here afterward, it felt important to observe rather than lead. Two of my academic advisors had been there that day, and through them and others, I had come to understand something of how profoundly the attack on the Dor Hadash, New Light and Tree of Life congregations had shaped this community.

I had helped prepare a grounding exercise, but I was unprepared for how quickly it would give way to nearly two hours of emotionally demanding conversation, especially around what Jews mean when we say “Never Again.” 

Back view of a person wearing a black shirt with a yellow Star of David and the text: “MAY THEIR MEMORY BE FOR A BLESSING,” followed by a list of names and ages.
“May their memory be for a blessing,” reads the shirt of a person watching survivors and victims’ families from the 2018 synagogue shooting as they talk to the media on Aug. 2, 2023, at the Jewish Community Center of Greater Pittsburgh in Squirrel Hill. (Photo by Stephanie Strasburg/Pittsburgh’s Public Source)

I grew up understanding those words as a universal moral obligation. My grandparents survived the Holocaust, and I inherited a conviction that remembering what happened to Jews carried responsibilities toward other people facing persecution. But I have increasingly encountered interpretations of Jewish history that emphasize our vulnerability as grounds for turning inward, for trusting only ourselves. One participant, seemingly a millennial like myself, recalled an Orthodox rabbi telling her during a Holocaust educational trip that nobody else would protect Jews. Only Jews could protect themselves.

That feeling of abandonment leading to insularity made immediate emotional sense to me. Jewish suffering is difficult to translate, an inherited anxiety shaped by generations of displacement and memories of betrayal by our neighbors. This memory is felt in our bones, or possibly our amygdalas, as my psychiatrist father would say. It doesn’t come across viscerally in our books or essays.

Her story brought me back to a visit I made to Dachau with my father while in high school. His uncles and relatives on his mother’s side had been imprisoned there. I remember him pointing out the beautiful houses in the surrounding Bavarian countryside, and remarking on the natural beauty of the place. He told me that the people who lived nearby knew what was happening. They could smell the smoke. The contrast between the idyllic surroundings and the indifference of the people made us both sick on that car ride to Dachau.

In my immediate family history, though, relatives survived the Holocaust because of their non-Jewish family members and colleagues. Their survival depended on relationships with people outside the Jewish community.

That history of Jewish interdependence took on particular significance in Pittsburgh, where the synagogue gunman’s antisemitism was inseparable from his hatred of immigrants and those who helped them. Eight years later, we were sitting together trying to understand what that connection demands of us today.

When grief meets grief

As we discussed what it means to show up for other communities, someone raised an observation about the vigils following the deaths of Antwon Rose Jr. and the 11 Jews murdered at Tree of Life. Members of Pittsburgh’s Black community had attended the vigil for the Jewish victims, but the same visible support from Jewish Pittsburghers had apparently been missing from gatherings mourning Rose, the 17-year-old killed by a police officer months earlier.

Three children hold signs at a protest, including one that reads, “Let us grow up stop killing.”
Several children attend a June 2018 rally in honor of Antwon Rose Jr., a 17-year-old fatally shot by a police officer. (Photo by Maranie Rae Staab/Pittsburgh’s Public Source)

I felt the sting of familiar pain. A few years ago, during a graduate seminar on race and gender, a Black woman had made the same observation. My first instinct then had been to defend my community. Surely there were Jews who had attended those vigils. Surely people had their reasons. And why should Jewish people have to demonstrate their solidarity with others before deserving compassion for their own suffering?

Several hundred people gather on Grant Street in front of the Allegheny County Courthouse in June 2018 to protest the death of Antwon Rose Jr. (Photo by Maranie Rae Staab/Pittsburgh’s Public Source)

I carried those objections with me. I also couldn’t quite dismiss what she had said.

Hearing the observation again, this time from within a Jewish discussion about solidarity, brought me back to the same tension. There are legitimate reasons to resist treating communal mourning as a test of moral innocence. Nobody should have to prove themselves worthy of compassion, particularly in the aftermath of violence. And an entire community cannot be measured by who happened to attend a particular vigil.

No community exists in isolation. Our relationships with others shape who we are, and the moments when we show up for their suffering become part of our own collective history. 

Those who attended the Tree of Life vigil may have recognized in the shooting a familiar threat from white supremacy. The perceived absence of Jewish community members at the Antwon Rose vigils, though, had left some people feeling abandoned. That feeling mattered to me, and it seemed to matter to the people gathered in that library.

A group of people standing at the front of a room behind a table with lit candles, facing an audience.
A remembrance marking the eight-year anniversary of the 2018 synagogue shooting at the Jewish Community Center in Squirrel Hill on Oct. 27. Loved ones of the victims light candles in memory of those lost. (Photo by Stephanie Strasburg/Pittsburgh’s Public Source)

I thought about the police officers who had risked their lives responding to the Tree of Life shooting, and about the officer who killed Antwon Rose just months earlier. Police officers had protected Jewish worshippers during one tragedy, while a police officer had caused another family’s loss. I wondered how these different experiences shaped what each community needed from its neighbors, especially when their experiences of the institutions meant to protect them differed so profoundly.

The experiences of immigrants facing detention brought these questions of solidarity into the present. Symone described visiting an immigrant detention facility near the southern border. She spoke of hearing children playing on the other side of the fence — children who had been taken from their parents and continued being children despite the coldness and cruelty of their imprisonment. 

At once, my thoughts went to my 8-year-old son, Rafael. I imagined him separated from me, somewhere I couldn’t reach him. I couldn’t bear the thought of hearing children playing behind a barrier and knowing that their parents might be unable to get to them.

That image also recalled the question I had carried since childhood. Growing up, I often imagined what I would have done had I lived in Germany during the Holocaust. I was certain I would have intervened. I pictured myself breaking rules, opening gates, doing whatever was necessary to help people escape. 

The confidence behind that imagined self has become harder to reconcile with my experience of the present. When reports of children being held in immigration detention facilities began emerging, I felt horrified. As a mother, the thought was almost unbearable. But I also felt powerless. I had spent my life believing that the greatest moral failure was to know about suffering and remain a bystander. Now I was living in a country where children were being detained, struggling to understand what meaningful intervention might look like.

Hearing Symone speak brought that helplessness back with unexpected force. I could no longer imagine myself opening the gates as easily as I had as a child.

Where to begin

But the people around the table had answers, at least to the question of where to begin.

Symone and others discussed Jewish organizers who had provided a protective presence outside a mosque following the San Diego mosque attack, offering security through community solidarity rather than policing. Others spoke about protesting immigration enforcement or volunteering at food pantries serving people beyond the Jewish community.

These were Pittsburghers who had been showing up for their neighbors long before we gathered at the library. I had arrived with some latent feelings about how communities fail one another, but the people around that table reminded me how much work Pittsburghers already devote to sustaining relationships across communities.

By the end of the two hours, I felt emotionally overwhelmed. I suggested that we take a moment to settle ourselves before leaving. But the mood in the room was also unexpectedly hopeful. We went around the table sharing what we were taking away and what we felt motivated to do. People offered resources and described ways to get involved. I gathered literature to take home.

A chain-link construction fence displaying a series of drawings and paintings in front of a brick building.
Drawings honoring those lost in the 2018 Pittsburgh synagogue shooting adorn the chain link fence surrounding the Tree of Life synagogue on Aug. 2, 2023, in Squirrel Hill. In 2018, the place of worship was the site of the most deadly antisemitic attack in U.S. history. (Photo by Stephanie Strasburg/Pittsburgh’s Public Source)

I still don’t have an easy answer to the observation that unsettled me in that classroom years ago. I want Jewish grief to be recognized without qualification, but I also want us to remain receptive when others tell us that we have failed to recognize theirs.

The gathering reminded me that willingness to listen is part of sustaining relationships across communities, and those relationships also depend on how we show up for one another. For me, bearing witness has increasingly come to mean living with that discomfort and allowing it to change what I do. I have always understood “Never Again” to demand something of us, no matter how far the suffering may seem from our own lives. I think about that demand when I remember the children Symone heard playing on the other side of the fence. Her retelling speaks to the child within me who would be determined to knock it down.

Ilana Spencer is a doctoral candidate in sociology at the University of Pittsburgh. Her research examines how religious communities negotiate gender, racial identity and political authority. Ilana can be reached at ics15@pitt.edu.

Help us keep telling stories like this one. Your gift is MATCHED up to 12x!

We’re Pittsburgh’s Public Source, an independent, nonprofit newsroom. That means we rely on donations from readers like you to help us report accurate, timely and impactful stories for the Pittsburgh region — available to everyone without paywalls.

And right now, you have a limited-time opportunity to supercharge your support. Through Dec. 31, our generous local match pool donors will match your new monthly donation 12 times or double your one-time gift until we reach our $80,000 goal!

We've seen our journalism prompt widespread change in the Pittsburgh region — but none of it would be possible without the support of our community. If you found this story valuable, consider "paying it forward" by making a gift today.

Creative Commons License

Republish our articles for free, online or in print, under a Creative Commons license.