Parents at West Mifflin Area School District are pushing back against a restructuring plan that would dissolve the district’s elementary schools and consolidate students in the middle school building. 

An online petition that has garnered over 500 signatures also called for the removal of Superintendent Jeffrey Soles and Assistant Superintendent Jeffrey Solomon and urged the district to halt the restructuring.

A person holds a smartphone displaying a Change.org petition about a school merger.
Samantha Fleming shows the petition she started to oppose a planned West Mifflin Area Schools merger as she waits to pick up her children from Homeville Elementary School on Nov. 17. Fleming, a graduate of the district, lives a few doors from where she grew up. (Photo by Stephanie Strasburg/Pittsburgh’s Public Source)

Samantha Fleming, a district parent who launched the petition, said a lack of transparency and clear communication with the community about the proposal has eroded trust in the administration. She said she called out the administration during a school board meeting asking them to focus on retaining families. 

“Why aren’t we digging into why the people of West Mifflin are losing confidence? Why they don’t feel like there is an ability for them, their kids, to go to school here and learn and grow?” she said.

A woman kneels outdoors with her arms around two young boys standing beside her.
Samantha Fleming with her children, Brody, left, 5, and Blake, 7, after picking them up from Homeville Elementary School on Nov. 17, in their town of West Mifflin. (Photo by Stephanie Strasburg/Pittsburgh’s Public Source)

Under the proposed restructuring, the district will move students from Clara Barton and Homeville — its two elementary schools — to the middle school building, which will be converted to a K-6 school. Students in grades seven through 12 would attend the high school building. The elementary school buildings would be repurposed to house the district administrative offices and the Titan Cyber Academy, a cyber program run by the district. 

Soles, the superintendent, said the district has provided weekly updates about the proposal and posted information on the district website. 

“I think we’ve been pretty transparent as to this and having open conversations about this,” he said. “I don’t think we hid anything.”

Clara Barton Elementary school sign reading “Clara Barton All Treats No Tricks.”
A sign outside Clara Barton Elementary School, Nov. 17, in West Mifflin. Under a proposed consolidation, Clara Barton wouild merge with Homeville Elementary and move to the district’s existing middle school building. (Photo by Stephanie Strasburg/Pittsburgh’s Public Source)

Restructuring driven by finances

The administration first began discussing the need for restructuring about 18 months ago, Soles said. Since then, it has undergone some changes after receiving community feedback. 

The district points to declining student enrollment, underutilized building capacity and rising operating costs as reasons for the restructuring. Soles said the consolidation is primarily driven by financial reasons resulting from a shrinking tax base and lower common-level ratio, a factor in calculating property tax assessments, which has lowered the levy for many commercial owners. 

“This is purely a financial position that we need to look at …” he said. “I think we do a great job educating kids here and doing what’s right for kids — it’s just that we have two large buildings that are not being utilized.”

A grey pickup truck drives past West Mifflin High School on a sunny autumn day.
A truck passes by West Mifflin Area High School, Nov. 17. The West Mifflin Area School District’s new restructuring plan, in the works for 18 months, aims to utilize the middle and high school buildings and repurpose the elementary school buildings. (Photo by Stephanie Strasburg/Pittsburgh’s Public Source)

The district projected a $2.8 million deficit in the 2026-27 budget and had an estimated fund balance of $2.9 million in June that’s projected to shrink to less than $100,000 by next summer.

West Mifflin’s student enrollment has declined by around 20% since 2018. According to district data, both the middle school and high school are operating at around two-thirds capacity.

The district also expects to lose students from Duquesne School District, which currently sends high schoolers to West Mifflin but is set to merge with McKeesport next year. 

A neighborhood of suburban houses nestled among trees with fall foliage.
Homes on the hillsides of West Mifflin, Nov. 17. The school district superintendent said shrinking tax base and enrollment have driven plans for school consolidation. (Photo by Stephanie Strasburg/Pittsburgh’s Public Source)

West Mifflin in numbers:

  • Student enrollment: 2,177
  • Number of students attending from Duquesne School District: 222
  • 2026-27 expenditures: $71.5 million
  • 2026-27 revenue: $68.7 million
  • Tax millage rate: 28.6137

The plan pledges to save the district $2.7 million a year by eliminating duplicated services, incentivizing employee retirements and reducing custodial and food service expenses, according to the district website. The biggest share of that ($1.2 million) is anticipated from employing fewer teachers through a combination of retirement incentives and attrition. The plan also calls for $400,000 in cuts to custodial staffing, $350,000 in cuts to administration, as well as reduced transportation and cafeteria costs. 

Soles said the high school and the middle school can hold 1,200 and 1,100 students respectively, and consolidating the buildings would make better use of existing resources while reducing costs.

A woman and two young boys standing by an open car door in a parking lot.
Samantha Fleming ushers her children, Blake and Brody, into their car after pickup from Homeville Elementary School, Nov. 17, (Photo by Stephanie Strasburg/Pittsburgh’s Public Source)

Parents want more details

The dissatisfaction with district leadership expressed in the petition is not the first time Soles has been under scrutiny. 

Soles was hired at the beginning of the 2020-21 school year on a five-year contract. In 2022, the West Mifflin Federation of Teachers overwhelmingly voted to demand his resignation, saying they had no confidence in his leadership because of a lack of communication and guidance during the pandemic. Teachers also alleged health and safety concerns were not addressed and they weren’t provided training to use technology.

The board instead voted to extend his contract in 2025, with a salary raise from $160,000 to $190,000. 

A blue banner on a pole reads “West Mifflin High School” and “Home of the Titans,” partially obscured by autumn leaves.
Leaves turn brown around a banner for West Mifflin Area High School, Nov. 17. The school district cited declining student enrollment, underutilized building capacity and rising operating costs as reasons for a restructuring plan. (Photo by Stephanie Strasburg/Pittsburgh’s Public Source)

In a formal letter submitted to the school board this month, community members alleged several issues, such as financial mismanagement, transportation failures, a lack of accountability and concerns regarding state funding as grounds for removal of the superintendent. 

Several parents raised complaints about inconsistent bus service at the beginning of the school year, which the district later addressed in a statement acknowledging driver shortages. Fleming said she was worried about how the district would be able to implement the merger if it could not fix the transportation issues. 

Soles said the restructuring plan would expedite student travel time and reduce bus runs by transporting more students together, saving $500,000. 

A man and a young girl wearing a pink fuzzy headband stand at a pizza counter, where the girl points toward the food inside a warming display case.
Tristan Smith orders a routine after-school slice of pizza for his daughter Maliha, 7, at Pizza Bistro on Nov. 17, in their town of West Mifflin. Smith worries that the special education services Maliha receives at Homeville Elementary will decline if the district lays off staff as part of the planned consolidation. (Photo by Stephanie Strasburg/Pittsburgh’s Public Source)

Tristan Smith, a parent who has a 7-year-old at Homeville Elementary, said the district has talked about potential savings from the consolidation without providing an estimate of how much it will cost to implement the plan. 

Parents also point to concerns with the condition of the building, citing a pending lawsuit between the district and a general contractor, claiming negligent work resulted in “cracking of the building infrastructure,” as well as moisture problems and exterior cracking. 

Soles declined to comment on the pending litigation.

Soles said the plan would not require any construction or renovation and would only incur expenses of moving furniture and other logistics. 

Smith said the district has not provided a full financial picture of remodeling costs or retirement costs for any staff members who would take early retirement. He said he is concerned that his daughter, who requires special education services, will lose access to some services if the district decides to save money by furloughing or laying off staff.

Soles said the district plans to provide early retirement incentives to employees and might furlough staff depending on the number of people who take early retirement. 

“I think that’s the big thing with the transparency,” Smith said. “They’re giving us these hypothetical numbers, but not talking about how much everything will actually cost to implement the plan.”

Lajja Mistry is the K-12 education reporter at Pittsburgh’s Public Source. She can be reached at lajja@publicsource.org. 

Help us keep telling stories like this one. Your gift is MATCHED up to 12x!

We’re Pittsburgh’s Public Source, an independent, nonprofit newsroom. That means we rely on donations from readers like you to help us report accurate, timely and impactful stories for the Pittsburgh region — available to everyone without paywalls.

And right now, you have a limited-time opportunity to supercharge your support. Through Dec. 31, our generous local match pool donors will match your new monthly donation 12 times or double your one-time gift until we reach our $80,000 goal!

We've seen our journalism prompt widespread change in the Pittsburgh region — but none of it would be possible without the support of our community. If you found this story valuable, consider "paying it forward" by making a gift today.

Creative Commons License

Republish our articles for free, online or in print, under a Creative Commons license.

Lajja is the K-12 education reporter at Pittsburgh's Public Source. Originally from India, she moved to the States in 2021 to pursue a master’s degree in journalism from the University of Southern California....