For nearly a year after giving birth, she cried in secret every day. She thought if she told anyone how she really felt they would take the baby away.
“It was almost like being an addict,” says Aasta Deth describing those days. “I knew I had to get through the work day and then I had 20 minutes from the time I got in my car until I got in the house and I could cry on the way home.”
During her son’s birth, Deth felt out of control and in the dark. Her labor was long and difficult, culminating in an emergency cesarean section. As a result of four hours of pushing and an attempt to turn the baby in utero, her son developed a blood blister spanning his scalp. It looked horrible, and no one reassured her that it wasn’t a major concern. Her son spent a week in the neonatal intensive care unit without any clear explanation why, and during this time her incision opened up and became infected.
Deth didn’t bond with her son, Sam, until he was almost 1.
“I honestly don’t have a lot of memories,” Deth said. “I remember feeling very detached from Sam emotionally. Like those middle-of-the-night crying spells, I would go through the motions of swinging, shushing, bouncing, but I really just wanted to go back to bed and I was more annoyed than concerned.”
She just thought that’s how motherhood was. It never occurred to her that her birth experience had anything to do with it. Because the sadness felt wrong, Deth minimized her feelings until she eventually sought counseling.
About a third of all births are emotionally traumatic for the mother, according to the nonprofit Prevention and Treatment of Traumatic Childbirth. Traumatic births involve feelings of imminent danger, helplessness or loss of control.
Trauma can be invisible, and postpartum women who are struggling emotionally can feel a lot of shame, said Sarah DeBrunner, a psychiatrist at Magee-Womens Hospital of UPMC. That shame may prevent them from getting the help that they need.
Life and death
Right after her daughter’s birth 15 months ago, Jefferson Hills resident Heather Abbruzzese hemorrhaged. Some amount of bleeding is normal after birth, but hers was excessive and it wasn’t stopping.
Abbruzzese’s doctor tried to staunch the flow by removing blood clots from inside her uterus.
“You could hear the blood sloshing into this garbage bag,” said Abbruzzese, 37. “Thinking about it now, my heart is racing because that was the most painful thing in the world. Unbelievably terrible pain.”
The doctor tried a few more interventions, but none of the usual tricks worked so she told Abbruzzese they would have to do surgery.
“At that point I said to her, ‘If I’m going to die, I just want to hold my baby,’” Abbruzzese said.
In the operating room, the doctors inserted a balloon into Abbruzzese’s uterus and filled it with saline to stop the bleeding. It worked. She lost about a third of her total blood volume. Over the next 24 hours, they deflated the balloon and the bleeding remained under control.
For 28-year-old Wilkinsburg resident Alissa Moss, it wasn’t her life that was in danger during childbirth, but her son’s.
Eight months ago, Moss had a placental abruption — where the placenta detaches from the uterus before the baby is born — in the 36th week of her pregnancy. Since the placenta is the fetus’ life line, physicians must react quickly to save the baby. About 1 percent of women experience a placental abruption and 12 percent of those cases result in stillbirth, according to a 2001 study.
Moss’ doctor performed an emergency C-section before her son suffocated. Her doctor told her they were within 10 minutes of getting him out in time.
“I almost had to come home to a house full of baby stuff without a baby,” Moss said. “I don’t think I could have done it. We would have had to put our house on the market and refused to come back.”
Fortunately for Moss, her son is healthy, but coming so close to the alternative left her shell-shocked. She couldn’t stop dwelling on the thought that she was almost not so lucky.
Each evening when the sun began to set, Moss would start to panic. She knew she should sleep, but she couldn’t bear to take her eyes off of her son. She compromised by sleeping on the nursery floor.
“I was terrified that if I went to sleep I would wake up and they would tell me that I just dreamt that we got him out in time,” Moss said.
Road to recovery
Of those mothers who experienced traumatic childbirth, approximately one third will develop posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD). Symptoms of PTSD include persistent flashbacks, bad dreams, frightening thoughts, avoidance and feeling on edge.
Members of racial minorities are at particular risk of developing PTSD after a traumatic event, and they are less likely to seek treatment, according to a 2011 study.
What are the barriers to recovering from traumatic birth? Lack of awareness and availability of resources are major factors.
“A big part of treating [psychological trauma] is recognition and access to care,” DeBrunner said. “Sometimes access to care is the limiting factor. That’s why our clinic exists.”
Magee’s Behavioral Health Services unit specializes in pregnant and postpartum mental health. The clinic is located inside Magee – two floors below the labor and delivery suites – and they accept health insurance.
“What drives me is to really help women do the best they can in pregnancy and postpartum,” DeBrunner said. “It should be a joyful time in their lives.”
Although DeBrunner said some women can benefit from medication to control their symptoms, sometimes talk therapy is enough. There are therapists at Behavioral Health Services as well as individuals like Kathy McGrath who specialize in traumatic birth counseling.
Over her 20-year career as a childbirth educator at Birth Partners, Inc., McGrath has met many women who experienced a traumatic birth. McGrath listens to each woman’s story, moment by moment. Her role is to provide validation and help them move on.
“To me, the definition of healing is being able to make the birth part of your life story and not front and center,” McGrath said.
Talk about it
Sometimes the traumatic event itself cannot be avoided, but what the hospital staff does in response can have a huge impact on how the woman perceives her birth and whether she develops PTSD, McGrath said.
Healthcare providers don’t receive formal training for preventing PTSD in patients, but obstetrician April Dunmyre tries to help her patients through emergency procedures by explaining what’s happening and why.
For instance, Dunmyre said she may tell a woman that an emergency C-section is best because the baby’s heart rate is low. Then she would mentally prepare the patient for the rush of people who will enter the room and provide reassurance that her partner can be in the operating room.
After the dust settles, Dunmyre debriefs the patient and answers questions.
“They might not be awake or alert enough or they might still be scared after they have their procedure,” said Dunmyre, who works at Magee Womancare Associates, “but then the next day the doctor or the midwife…will discuss with them what happened.”
In Deth’s case, these conversations would have been helpful. She said a lot of the negative aspects of her birth and the aftermath were caused by a lack of clear communication.
The turning point for Deth and Moss in processing their traumatic births was discovering New Mom’s Coffee (NMC). McGrath and Kids Plus Pediatrics created NMC as a donation-based support group for new mothers.
At NMC, Deth said all of a sudden she could put words to how she felt. She shared her birth story and the group provided validation that these things were indeed traumatizing. The other NMC moms encouraged her to seek counseling with McGrath, which ultimately helped her to reframe her birth story and repair her fraught relationship with her son, who is now 4.
“I remember sitting in the yard with my son, right before his first birthday,” about four months after joining NMC, Deth said. “He was doing his funny walk-crawl thing that we referred to as his three-legged race … and just laughing while he ran around the yard, and I realized that, at that moment, this is exactly where I wanted to be.”
A year later, Deth gave birth to a daughter. She describes this one as her “healing birth,” because everything went right.
Moss hopes for a healing birth some day, but she said she would need extensive therapy during the pregnancy to quell her fears that she might have a repeat abruption.
Before coming to NMC, Moss said she wasn’t really aware of the concept of traumatic birth. So many people had fed her the line that she should just be grateful her baby is healthy, but at NMC she was given the space to vent about how emotionally challenging it is to almost lose a child.
Part of the reason McGrath started NMC is to help women who underwent a traumatic birth not to feel alone and to find validation for their lingering negative emotions.
“I think all of us need to be aware that just because the baby was OK it doesn’t necessarily mean it was a good experience,” McGrath said. “You don’t need to pry for details, but just open the door to talk with her about it. You don’t need to try to put a happy spin on it.”
Erin Hare is a freelance writer, neuroscience Ph.D. candidate, and mother to an awesome little boy who shares her love of language. She can be reached at email@example.com or you can follow her @sciencetosense.
We don't have paywalls — but your support helps us bridge crucial information gaps.
Readers tell us they can't find the information they get from our reporting anywhere else, and we're glad to provide this important service for our community. We work hard to produce accurate, timely, impactful journalism without paywalls that keeps our region informed and moving forward.
However, only about .1% of the people who read our stories contribute to our work financially. Our newsroom depends on the generosity of readers like yourself to make our high-quality local journalism possible, and the costs of the resources it takes to produce it have been rising, so each member means a lot to us.
Your donation to our nonprofit newsroom helps ensure everyone in Allegheny County can stay up-to-date about decisions and events that affect them. Please make your gift of support now.